1991 Design Standards
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 is one of the most comprehensive pieces of civil rights legislation in the United States that prohibits discrimination against individuals with disabilities.
The ADA was enacted on July 26, 1990, and was signed into law by President George H.W. Bush. It was primarily inspired by the civil rights movement and is modeled after earlier landmark laws such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The purpose of the ADA is to ensure that people with disabilities have the same rights and opportunities as everyone else. This includes the right to participate in mainstream life — to enjoy employment opportunities, to purchase goods and services, and to participate in state and local government programs and services.
Key Titles of the ADA
The ADA is divided into five titles, each addressing different areas of public life:
- Title I – Employment: This title prohibits employers with 15 or more employees from discriminating against qualified individuals with disabilities in job application procedures, hiring, firing, advancement, compensation, job training, and other terms, conditions, and privileges of employment.
- Title II – Public Services: This section covers all activities of state and local governments regardless of the government entity’s size or receipt of federal funding. Title II requires public entities to be accessible to individuals with disabilities.
- Title III – Public Accommodations and Services Operated by Private Entities: It requires places of public accommodation, operated by private entities, to be accessible to individuals with disabilities. Examples include privately-owned, leased or operated facilities like hotels, restaurants, retail merchants, doctor’s offices, golf courses, private schools, day care centers, health clubs, sports stadiums, movie theaters, etc.
- Title IV – Telecommunications: This title requires telephone and Internet companies to provide a nationwide system of interstate and intrastate telecommunications relay services that enable individuals with hearing or speech disabilities to communicate over the telephone.
- Title V – Miscellaneous Provisions: It includes a range of provisions relating to the ADA as a whole, including its relationship to other laws, state immunity, its impact on insurance providers and benefits, prohibition against retaliation and coercion, illegal use of drugs, and attorney’s fees.
Advocacy and Development
The ADA was the result of years of advocacy by the disability community and many dedicated activists. Notable figures such as Justin Dart Jr., often considered the “Father of the ADA,” and others played significant roles in gathering support and pushing for the legislation. These efforts included extensive lobbying, public protests, and demonstrations to highlight the need for comprehensive protections.
Since its enactment, the ADA has had a profound impact on millions of Americans, offering protections from discrimination and increasing accessibility in various aspects of public life. It has also inspired similar laws worldwide, promoting global awareness and action towards disability rights.
The ADA not only marked a pivotal moment in civil rights legislation but continues to evolve as society and technology change, ensuring ongoing improvements in accessibility and inclusion for individuals with disabilities.
Importance of Design Standards in Promoting Accessibility
Design standards like those outlined in the ADA ensure that people with disabilities have equal access to public spaces and services. This includes access to buildings, restrooms, transportation, and digital spaces. By providing a clear set of guidelines, these standards help to eliminate physical and social barriers that might exclude people with disabilities from fully participating in society.
Promoting Independence and Autonomy
Accessible design standards empower individuals with disabilities by promoting their independence and autonomy. When environments are designed with accessibility in mind, people with disabilities can move freely, use facilities without assistance, and engage more actively in community and professional activities. This boosts their confidence and ability to manage daily activities on their own terms.
Legal Compliance and Avoidance of Litigation
For businesses and public entities, adhering to design standards isn’t just a matter of ethical responsibility—it’s also a legal requirement. Compliance with ADA standards helps avoid potential lawsuits and costly legal disputes. More importantly, it protects organizations from the reputational damage that can arise from failing to meet accessibility requirements.
Economic Inclusion
Accessible design opens up economic opportunities for people with disabilities by removing barriers to employment, education, and commerce. This inclusion benefits not only individuals but the economy as a whole. Businesses that adhere to accessibility standards can tap into a larger customer base, improve customer satisfaction, and foster a more diverse workforce.
Enhancing Usability for All
Design standards that focus on accessibility often result in improvements that benefit a broader audience. Features such as ramps, wide doorways, clear signage, and intuitive website design can enhance usability for older adults, parents with strollers, people with temporary injuries, and many others, not just those with permanent disabilities.
Disability rights before the ADA
Before the enactment of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in 1990, the disability rights landscape in the United States was significantly different, characterized by a patchwork of laws and policies that varied widely across states and sectors. The journey toward the ADA involved several important milestones and legislative actions that laid the groundwork for this comprehensive civil rights legislation. Here’s a look at the key developments in disability rights before the ADA:
Rehabilitation Act of 1973
One of the earliest federal laws specifically designed to address the needs of individuals with disabilities was the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. This legislation was groundbreaking, particularly Section 504, which states that “no qualified individual with a disability in the United States shall be excluded from, denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity that receives Federal financial assistance.” Section 504 was the first U.S. federal civil rights protection for people with disabilities and set a precedent for subsequent laws, including the ADA.
Architectural Barriers Act of 1968
This act was one of the first to address the needs of people with disabilities by requiring that all buildings designed, constructed, or altered with federal funds must be accessible. The Architectural Barriers Act laid the foundation for later legislation focused on environmental and architectural accessibility.
Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975 (now IDEA)
This law, now known as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), mandated that public schools provide all children with disabilities access to free and appropriate public education, tailored to their individual needs. This was a significant shift toward inclusive education, ensuring that children with disabilities could learn in classrooms alongside their non-disabled peers.
Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988
This act extended civil rights protections to people with disabilities in the context of housing. It prohibited discrimination based on disability (and family status) in the sale, rental, and financing of dwellings. It also required landlords to allow tenants with disabilities to make reasonable access-related modifications to their living units at their own expense.
Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act
First enacted in 1975 and later amended, this act aimed to assist states and community agencies in the development of and access to comprehensive services and supports for people with developmental disabilities. It focused on enhancing the independence, productivity, and integration and inclusion of people with disabilities into the community.
Public and Social Movements
Besides legislative action, the disability rights movement, which grew in power during the 1970s and 1980s, played a crucial role in advocating for these laws and for broader changes. Activists conducted sit-ins, protests, and other forms of civil disobedience to demand equal rights and opportunities for people with disabilities. These actions, inspired by the civil rights and women’s rights movements, highlighted the systemic barriers faced by people with disabilities and pushed for societal change.
Key Features of the 1991 Standards
The 1991 ADA Standards for Accessible Design set forth a wide range of requirements to ensure that buildings and facilities are accessible to individuals with disabilities. These standards were groundbreaking at the time, providing detailed guidance on the design and construction of accessible environments. Here are the key features of the 1991 ADA standards:
General Provisions
- Scope and Application: The standards applied to all areas of newly constructed and altered state and local government facilities, public accommodations, and commercial facilities.
- Accessible Routes: Specifications were provided for pathways, including corridors, doorways, floors, ramps, elevators, and lifts to ensure they are usable by people with disabilities, particularly those using wheelchairs.
Specific Elements
- Parking and Drop-off Areas: Designated accessible parking spaces were required to be closest to accessible entrances and have adequate size and marking. Van-accessible parking spaces with sufficient height and width to accommodate vans with lifts were also mandated.
- Entrances: At least half of all public entrances needed to be made accessible, with specifications for door hardware, threshold slopes, and opening force.
- Ramps and Walkways: Guidelines included the slope, width, and surface of ramps, with handrails and landing requirements to aid mobility for those with physical disabilities.
- Stairs: All steps on a stairway had to have uniform riser heights and tread depths, with handrails that complied with specific standards to assist those with mobility and balance impairments.
Facilities and Room Configurations
- Restrooms: Detailed requirements for accessible toilet stalls, urinals, lavatories, and controls. This included specifications for grab bars, spacing, and heights to accommodate wheelchair users.
- Telephones: Public telephones needed to be accessible, with provisions for height and clear floor space to accommodate wheelchair users. Text telephones (TTYs) or similar devices were required in buildings with four or more public payphones.
- Drinking Fountains: Guidelines were provided for accessible drinking fountains, including requirements for spout height and knee clearance.
- Seating, Tables, and Counters: Requirements were set for accessible seating in assembly areas, including theaters and conference rooms, and accessible tables in dining areas and workspaces.
Signage and Alarms
- Signage: Specifications for the design and placement of signs identifying permanent rooms and spaces ensured they could be read by individuals with visual impairments, including braille and tactile characters.
- Alarms: Requirements for audible and visual alarm systems to alert people with hearing impairments during emergencies.
Specialized Facilities
- Housing: Accessibility requirements in housing units in buildings without elevators, including accessible routes into and through the dwelling units, accessible light switches, outlets, and environmental controls.
- Recreational Facilities: Although more detailed standards for recreational facilities were developed later, the initial standards covered some aspects of accessibility for parks, gyms, and other recreational areas.
The 1991 ADA standards were significant in their comprehensive approach to various elements of physical accessibility. They set the stage for subsequent updates and refinements that continued to improve accessibility standards in response to technological advancements and broader societal changes. The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design, for example, further expanded and clarified many of the requirements introduced in 1991, continuing to evolve the landscape of accessible design.
Accessibility Requirements
The 1991 ADA Standards for Accessible Design established detailed requirements for various aspects of physical and communication accessibility in public spaces and commercial facilities. Here’s an overview of the key specifications:
Accessibility Requirements for Physical Structures
- Doorways: Doorways needed to have a minimum clear opening width of 32 inches when the door is open to 90 degrees, to accommodate wheelchair access. The threshold height was restricted to minimize the barrier for wheel passage, and hardware such as handles, pulls, latches, locks, and other operable parts had to be usable with one hand, without tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist.
- Ramps: Ramps were required where changes in level are unavoidable. The slope of a ramp could not exceed a 1:12 ratio, which means for every inch of vertical rise, there had to be at least 12 inches of ramp run. Additionally, ramps must have handrails if the rise is greater than 6 inches or the length is greater than 72 inches.
- Elevators: Elevators had to be accessible with features such as lowered buttons with braille and tactile markings, adequate interior dimensions to accommodate a wheelchair, and audible signals to indicate the arrival of the elevator and the direction of travel.
Specifications for Parking, Signage, and Public Facilities
- Parking: Accessible parking spaces were designated with specific size requirements and an adjacent access aisle to facilitate the deployment of lifts from vans and other mobility devices. These spaces were required to be located on the shortest accessible route to the building entrance or facility they serve.
- Signage: Signage identifying permanent rooms and spaces had to include tactile characters and braille. Directional and informational signage also needed to be clear and easy to read, using non-glare backgrounds and characters that contrast with their background.
Public Facilities:
- Restrooms: Must include features such as wider stalls, grab bars, lower-mounted sinks, and toilets, and lever-operated, push-type, or otherwise touchless water controls.
- Seating Areas: In theaters, auditoriums, and other seating areas, a specific number of wheelchair-accessible spaces were required, along with companion seating and lines of sight compliant with visibility requirements.
Standards for Communication Accessibility
- Visual Alarms: In places where audible alarms are present, visual alarms were also required. These visual alarms must be integrated into the building or facility’s emergency warning system to ensure accessibility for individuals with hearing impairments.
- Braille Signage: Alongside tactile text, braille translations were necessary for signage to assist visually impaired individuals in navigating buildings independently.
Amendments and Updates to the Standards
The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design marked a significant update to the original 1991 standards, reflecting advances in technology, changes in the use of spaces, and a better understanding of the needs of people with disabilities. Introduced by the Department of Justice, these standards became mandatory on March 15, 2012, and applied to all construction and alterations after this date.
The 2010 update aimed to address gaps and ambiguities found in the 1991 standards and incorporate technological advancements that had emerged over the past two decades. This update was also influenced by changes in demographic trends, such as the aging population, which further emphasized the need for accessible design.
Key Changes and Additions
The 2010 standards maintained the basic requirements of the 1991 standards but introduced several significant enhancements and clarifications:
- Recreational Facilities: One of the most notable additions was the inclusion of detailed accessibility guidelines for various types of recreational facilities, including swimming pools, playgrounds, golf courses, and exercise facilities. These new guidelines ensured that recreational areas would be more accessible to individuals with disabilities.
- Residential Facilities: The standards extended more comprehensive accessibility requirements to residential facilities, particularly those in public housing or buildings receiving federal funding.
- Reach Ranges and Maneuvering Space: The updated standards adjusted the required reach ranges and maneuvering space to reflect more current data on the use of mobility aids and the physical capabilities of people with disabilities.
- Technology Integration: The standards also addressed newer technologies, such as video relay service (VRS) hardware, which was not widespread when the original standards were drafted. This update ensured that communication technologies within buildings were accessible.
- Building Elements: Updated standards provided clearer guidelines on various building elements such as stairways, handrails, and walking surfaces, improving safety and usability.
The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design significantly impacted how public spaces are constructed and altered in the U.S. They provided a more inclusive framework that not only addressed the needs of people with disabilities more comprehensively but also responded to the public and industry feedback on the practicalities of implementing the 1991 standards. This update allowed for greater flexibility in some areas, providing alternatives and exceptions where strict compliance was impractical or unnecessary, without compromising on accessibility.
With the introduction of these standards, businesses and public entities were given a compliance deadline to ensure that new constructions and renovations adhered to the updated guidelines. This transition period helped entities adjust to the new requirements without undue financial burden.
The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design represent a pivotal improvement in the commitment to equality and accessibility for all individuals, reinforcing the principles laid out in the ADA by adapting to the evolving landscape of architectural design and technology.